Are Top-Tier Keyword Domains Valuable in Any Extension?

With hundreds of new extensions on the horizon, there’s a tendency to forget that hundreds of extensions already exist. Country-code extensions make up the vast majority of them, with a significant amount of them not very popular, even within their country.

I know many extensions like .vg, .ms, .tc and others intimately as I’ve bought and sold quite a few top-tier keywords in those extensions in the past. Many years ago, the growing online poker phenomenon caused the word “poker” to have value in every extension. At it’s peak, there was a fairly defined minimum of $1,500 for Poker.anything. I was ultimately involved in 7 sales of Poker in country-code extensions including Poker.in for $60,000.

Poker was a booming online business at the time and many believed that these Poker.anything domains could help rank a site highly on Google for poker. Additionally, the names were shorter than what could be had in .com or another mainstream extension for the same price. Rather than having to remember some random word or two along with poker in a .com, why not just 2 letters after the dot?

In the past few years, we’ve seen some previously obscure country-code extensions get used more, particularly for short domains. The popularity of Twitter saw extensions like .ly, .gd, .nu and others come to sudden life. But has that expanded into generic keywords in those extensions?

No. Top-tier keywords are not valuable in merely any extension. In fact, the only domains valuable in pretty much every extension are single-letter domains thanks to the short domain craze.

Why aren’t top-tier keywords valuable in every extension?

1. SEO benefits of them haven’t held up

While initially, Google may not have treated extensions all that differently, over time it became apparent that they were. Case in point, Google had to announce that .co would be treated like a gTLD after it was released globally by the registry. Reading between the lines, country-code extensions do not get the same treatment internationally as com/net/org and other gTLDs.

You might think “but still, it’s an exact match domain!” Keep in mind, SEO as an industry has grown by leaps and bounds over the past 5 years. It’s impossible to rank highly for terms like poker without long-term and extensive SEO efforts. The strength of exact match coupled with the weakness of a poor extension would make the domain worth a drop in the bucket for SEO.

2. High registration costs

Keeping a .com registered for 5 years isn’t a huge pain in the wallet, but a .cg or .md would be. Those are two of a number of extensions that cost over $100 per year to register. Lower-cost obscure country-code extensions are around $30-$40 per year, so at best it’s still 3-4 times the cost of a .com. Ultimately these costs started to turn off buyers.

3. A largely reseller-driven market

Sure, it likely took a few sales of Poker.ext domains to end-users to help establish a market for them. Once that market got going though, it was fueled almost entirely by resellers. After all, if the values were seemingly shooting up from out of nowhere, there was no telling how high they could end up.

All that said, top-tier keywords are valuable in most extensions, and in most of those extensions they are THE most valuable domains. Trends may be moving towards short brandables given the social media trends of using them, but top-tier keywords are still usually the kings of their extension.

Advertisements

3 Comments on “Are Top-Tier Keyword Domains Valuable in Any Extension?”

  1. DomainFuze! says:

    I wish this post had been around prior to a recent top tier keyword investment we made in an obscure ccTLD. ASSumed we’d make a killing on it because it had so much going for it: 1) A 2 char domain 2) The best 2 char domain possible: ‘3d’ 3) Huge retail and development potential…the list goes on. Regardless of those positives…nobody wanted it. Simple as that. Can’t make a killing on a domain that nobody wants. Ended up taking a loss on it…and everyone learned a valuable lesson.

    Thanks for the post. Tweeted it out, in hopes that it convinces people to do their research, rather than ASSuming, like we did.

  2. Keyword rich domains definitely provide short term wins.

    If you can find a profitable niche with low to medium competition a keyword rich domain can be a quick way to achieve a first page ranking.

    However, if you are looking to build a brand and focus on multiple different markets it might be a better idea to choose a domain name that is unique to your business.

    This may save some money !

  3. Sharon Hayes says:

    Reblogged this on Sharon Hayes Dot Com.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s